This is the second of the three turkeys I cooked for Thanksgiving this year, and it is the one built for people who hate dry turkey. The bird is spatchcocked, which means the backbone comes out and the turkey is pressed flat, and then it goes on the smoker at 300 to 350 degrees until the thigh reads 165. Flat bird, even cook, crisp skin everywhere. That is the whole pitch, and it works.
Why I Cook It This Way
A whole round turkey is a shape problem. The breast sits high and exposed and dries out while the thick thighs tucked underneath are still trying to finish. By the time the dark meat is done, the white meat has given up. Flattening the bird removes the problem completely. A spatchcocked turkey is one even thickness from end to end, so the heat reaches everything at the same rate and the breast and the thighs finish together. Every inch of skin faces the heat and the smoke, so all of it crisps and all of it takes on smoke, instead of just the top. If you have ever carved a smoked turkey and wished the whole bird tasted like the best slice, this is how you get there.
The Snap Is The Whole Trick
Removing the backbone is the heavy work, and you want real poultry shears for it, because those bones are thick and a small knife will fight you the whole way. Once the backbone is out, flip the bird over and press down hard on the center of the breast with both hands. You will hear a loud snap. That sound is the breastbone and ribs giving way, and it is what lets the turkey lay completely flat on the grate. Do not be gentle here. A bird that is almost flat cooks almost evenly, and that is not the same thing.
Seasoning A Flat Bird
There is no cavity to hide seasoning in on a spatchcocked turkey, so everything goes on the surface, both sides. I mix the five seasonings together and coat the whole bird liberally, top and bottom, because every bit of that surface is going to be somebody’s favorite bite. Season it after it is flat, not before, so the rub lands on the bird in the shape it will actually cook in.
How To Know It Is Done
The thigh still makes the call. Cook until the thickest part of the thigh reads 165 degrees with the thermometer in the meat and not on bone. Because the bird is flat, the breast and thigh readings land close together on this one, and that is exactly the point of cooking it this way. Rest it before carving so the juices settle. A spatchcocked turkey is also the easiest of the three to carve. The legs pull away clean, the breast slices in even pieces, and nothing hides in a deep cavity.
Carving And Leftovers
Carve the breast in thick slices and separate the legs and thighs at the joint. Leftovers keep three to four days in the fridge and freeze well. The smoked meat makes an unreal leftover sandwich the next day, which around here is not a side benefit. It is part of the plan.
Watch the full video to see all three turkeys side by side, and check out the other two birds, the grilled beer butt turkey and the oven roasted stuffed turkey, plus all six of my Thanksgiving sides in the Holiday Recipes collection.
Smoked Spatchcock Turkey Recipe
Ingredients
Method
- Place the turkey breast-side down on a sturdy board. With heavy kitchen shears, cut along both sides of the backbone from the tail to the neck and remove the backbone completely.
- Flip the turkey breast-side up and press firmly down on the center of the breast with both hands until you hear a loud snap — that is the breastbone and ribs giving way so the turkey lays flat.
- Mix all the seasonings together and coat the turkey liberally with the rub, on both sides.
- Smoke at 300°F to 350°F for about 4 hours, until the thickest part of the thigh reads 165°F.
- Rest the turkey, then carve.


Leave a Reply