This year I cooked three turkeys three different ways for Thanksgiving, and this is the one that happened on the grill. The bird stands upright on a beer can and roasts in the heat of the grill with the lid down. It looks like a gimmick and I know that, but there is real logic in it, and the turkey that came off that grill earned its place next to the other two.
Why I Cook It This Way
A turkey lying in a pan steams on the bottom and roasts on the top, and those two halves never quite match. Standing the bird upright fixes that. Hot air moves around the whole turkey, so the skin crisps on every side instead of going soft where it sat in its own juices. The beer in the can warms up and steams the bird gently from the inside while the outside roasts, and the legs splay forward into the same heat as the breast, so the dark meat and the white meat finish closer together. There is also a practical reason I love this method. The grill does the work outside, which leaves the oven completely free for the sides, and on Thanksgiving the oven is the busiest place in the house.
Before You Start
Check your grill before the bird is seasoned and waiting. A 20 pound turkey standing on a can is tall, and the lid has to close all the way with room to spare. Pour off about half the beer before you set the bird on the can. A full can boils over and makes a mess, and half a can is plenty for steam. Get a second person if you can. Moving a hot upright turkey is the hardest part of this whole recipe, and it is much easier with help.
My Tips From This Cook
Pat the skin dry before the rub goes on. Dry skin is what turns crisp, and wet skin steams no matter how good your rub is. The rub makes a big batch on purpose, so use it everywhere, all over the outside and inside the cavity too. Keep the lid closed as much as you can. Every peek lets the heat out and adds time. Start checking the temperature early rather than late, because a bird that is done early can rest, and a bird that is done late holds up the whole dinner.
How To Know It Is Done
Cook the turkey until the thickest part of the thigh reads 165 degrees, with the thermometer pushed into the meat and not touching bone. The breast will read a little lower and that is fine, because the thigh is the part that needs the time. Let the bird rest before you carve it. The juices settle back into the meat while it rests, and a carved too early turkey leaks all of that onto the board.
Carving And Leftovers
Take the bird off the can with care, because the can and the beer inside it are very hot. Carve the breast in thick slices and pull the legs and thighs away in whole pieces. Leftovers keep three to four days in the fridge and freeze well for later. Around here leftover turkey means sandwiches, and honestly that is half the reason to cook a bird this size.
Watch the full video to see all three turkeys side by side, and check out the other two birds, the smoked spatchcock turkey and the oven roasted stuffed turkey, plus all six of my Thanksgiving sides in the Holiday Recipes collection.
Grilled Beer Butt Turkey Recipe
Ingredients
Method
- Mix all the seasonings together to make the rub, and coat the turkey liberally with it, inside and outside.
- Open the beer can and pour off about half the beer. Set the can upright and lower the turkey's cavity down over the can so the bird sits upright, using the can and its legs as a tripod.
- Grill at 300°F to 350°F with the lid closed for about 4 hours, until the thickest part of the thigh reads 165°F.
- Carefully lift the turkey off the can (the can and the liquid inside are very hot), rest it, then carve.


Leave a Reply