Steak tenderloin sandwich with chimichurri cut in half and held in two hands, showing medium rare sliced tenderloin and chimichurri dripping out of a toasted ciabatta roll

Steak Tenderloin Sandwich with Chimichurri

Reverse seared beef tenderloin sliced thin and piled onto a toasted baguette with bright homemade chimichurri and a tangy mustard mayo. Steakhouse flavor in sandwich form, and the whole thing is built on cooking the steak to temperature instead of guessing.

Prep Time: 15 minutes

Cook Time: 20 minutes

Total Time: 45 minutes

Servings: 1 sandwich per tenderloin, chimichurri makes a full batch

Cooking Method: Reverse Sear (Oven and Stovetop)

Cuisine: Argentinian Inspired

Course: Lunch, Dinner

Steak Tenderloin Sandwich with Chimichurri

This Steak Tenderloin Sandwich with Chimichurri is the sandwich I make when I want a steakhouse dinner without the steakhouse bill. Tenderloin is the most tender cut on the cow and it usually gets saved for special occasions. Sliced thin and stacked on good bread with a loud chimichurri, it eats like a steakhouse decided to make sandwiches.

The move that makes it work is the reverse sear. The medallions go into a low oven first and come up slow and even. Then a hard sear at the end builds the crust. Edge to edge pink, no gray ring, no guessing. You are cooking to a thermometer reading and not to a timer, and that is why it lands every single time.

The chimichurri does the heavy lifting on flavor. It is all acid and herbs with garlic and a little heat from the Fresno, and it cuts right through the richness of the beef. The mustard mayo underneath keeps every bite creamy and gives the steak something tangy to sit on.

Why Tenderloin, and Why This Works With Any Steak

Real talk, this chimichurri and this spread work on any beef you put between bread. I have made this exact sandwich with skirt steak. I have made it with ribeyes. I have put it on brisket. Any kind of beef steak style sandwich, that chimichurri with that spread works perfectly, so do not feel like you have to use it on tenderloin only.

I just like tenderloin for this, and the reason is the bite. In a sandwich you do not want a chewy piece of steak. With a tougher cut you take one bite and the whole piece of steak comes out of the sandwich with it. Tenderloin is so tender that you bite straight through it and just enjoy a steak sandwich. No tug of war, no wearing the filling. That clean bite is the whole reason tenderloin is my pick here.

Why You’ll Love This Steak Tenderloin Sandwich with Chimichurri

  • Edge to edge medium rare. The low oven brings the steak up evenly so the whole medallion cooks the same instead of a gray band around a raw center.
  • The crust still shows up. A ripping hot sear at the end gives you the browned beefy crust tenderloin usually misses.
  • Chimichurri does the seasoning for you. Bright and acidic with garlic and Fresno heat, it wakes up every bite and balances the rich cut.
  • The chimichurri makes a real batch. Two cups each of cilantro and parsley means the sauce is handled for this round and the next one.
  • No grill required. Oven and a hot pan, that is the whole setup.

Kitchen Tools You’ll Need

  • Instant read thermometer: The entire method runs on internal temperature, so this is not optional.
  • Rimmed baking sheet with a rack: Holds the medallions in the low oven and lets air move under the meat.
  • Cast iron skillet: The heaviest pan you own gives the hardest sear in the shortest time.
  • Sharp slicing knife: Thin slices against the grain are what make tenderloin eat tender in a sandwich.
  • Tongs: For flipping medallions without piercing them and losing juice.

Donaldo’s Tips

  • Season heavier than you think. Tenderloin is a mild cut and the medallions are thick, so the salt and pepper have to do real work.
  • Let the steak sit out first. If the medallions go into the oven cold they take longer and cook less evenly. Let them sit until they are not cold anymore, then the low oven only needs about 15 to 20 minutes.
  • Pull at 105 degrees. The sear adds the rest. If you wait for the oven to take it all the way, the sear pushes it past medium rare.
  • Trust the thermometer over the clock. The 15 to 20 minutes is a range, and your thermometer is the accurate read. Check it.
  • Get the pan properly hot before the sear. The steak is already cooked inside, so the pan time is only about crust. Lukewarm pan time just overcooks it.
  • Rest it even though it is small. Five to eight minutes keeps the juice in the meat instead of on the cutting board.
  • Slice thin and against the grain. Look at which way the fibers run and cut across them. Thick slices of even the most tender cut will chew tough in a sandwich.
  • Sauce like you mean it. Mustard mayo on both pieces of bread and a heavy layer of chimichurri across the steak. That thick layer is the sandwich.

Ingredient Substitutions

  • Tenderloin: Skirt steak, ribeye, or even brisket all take this chimichurri and spread perfectly. The cook changes with the cut, but the build stays exactly the same.
  • Fresno pepper: A jalapeño brings close heat, and a pinch of red pepper flakes works if there is no fresh chili around.
  • Red wine vinegar: Sherry vinegar is the closest swap and keeps the sharp edge the sauce needs.
  • Old style mustard: Any whole grain mustard works, and Dijon makes a smoother and sharper spread.
  • Ciabatta baguette: A sturdy sourdough loaf sliced thick holds up to the juice just as well.

What to Serve With Steak Tenderloin Sandwich with Chimichurri

This is a rich sandwich, so the sides should stay fresh and crunchy.

  • Crispy oven fries or smashed potatoes
  • A simple green salad with lemon
  • Grilled corn or a quick cucumber salad
  • Pickled red onions on the side for anyone who wants more acid

How to Store and Reheat Leftover Tenderloin

Refrigerating

Store the sliced steak, the chimichurri, and the spread in separate containers for up to 3 days. Keeping the sauce off the meat stops the acid from turning the surface gray.

Reheating

Warm the slices gently in a low oven until just heated through. A hot pan will cook them past medium rare in seconds, so low and slow is the safe move. Build the sandwich fresh after the meat is warm.

Freezing

Freeze the unsliced cooked tenderloin wrapped tight for up to 2 months. The chimichurri freezes well in a small jar or an ice cube tray. Thaw both in the fridge overnight before building.

Steak Tenderloin Sandwich with Chimichurri Recipe

Reverse seared tenderloin sliced thin on toasted ciabatta with homemade chimichurri and mustard mayo.
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Total Time 45 minutes
Servings: 1 sandwich
Course: Dinner, Lunch
Cuisine: Argentinian Inspired

Ingredients
  

For the Tenderloin
  • 1 small beef tenderloin per sandwich, cut into medallions
  • Kosher salt, heavy
  • Black pepper, heavy
For the Chimichurri
  • 2 cups cilantro
  • 2 cups parsley
  • 3 cloves garlic, chopped finely
  • 1 Fresno pepper, chopped fine
  • 1 cup red wine vinegar
  • 1 cup olive oil
For the Mustard Mayo Spread
  • Mayo
  • Old style whole grain mustard, equal parts with the mayo
For the Sandwiches
  • Sourdough or ciabatta baguette

Method
 

  1. Season the Steak. Season the tenderloin medallions heavily on all sides with salt and pepper. Tenderloin is mild and thick, so do not be shy with it. Let the medallions sit out until they are not cold anymore.
  2. Make the Chimichurri. Stir the cilantro, parsley, garlic, Fresno pepper, red wine vinegar, and olive oil together in a bowl. Set it aside so the flavors can settle while the steak cooks.
  3. Mix the Spread. Stir equal parts mayo and old style whole grain mustard together and keep it in the fridge until it is time to build.
  4. Low Oven First. Put the medallions in the oven at 280°F and cook until the internal temperature reads about 105°F on an instant read thermometer. If the steak sat out and is not cold, this takes about 15 to 20 minutes tops, but check it with the thermometer to be super accurate. The meat comes up slow and even, and that is the whole point of the reverse sear.
  5. Sear for the Crust. Take the medallions out and sear them in a ripping hot pan on both sides until a deep crust forms. The sear brings the internal temperature up to medium rare, about 130-135°F.
  6. Rest and Slice. Rest the steak for 5 to 8 minutes. It is a small cut, so it does not need long. Then slice it thin against the grain.
  7. Build the Sandwiches. Toast the sourdough or ciabatta baguette. Spread the mustard mayo on the bottom bread, layer the sliced tenderloin across in thin layers, then lay a heavy layer of chimichurri across all of it. More spread on the top piece of bread, then close it.

Notes

The thermometer runs this recipe. Pull at 105 before the sear and finish at 130-135.
If the steak goes in cold it needs longer in the oven. Let it sit out first.
Thin slices against the grain are non-negotiable for a tender bite.
Make the chimichurri first so it has time to settle while the steak cooks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why pull the steak at 105 degrees?

The sear at the end adds 25 to 30 degrees. Pulling at 105 leaves room for that climb so the steak lands at a true medium rare instead of blowing past it.

Why does the steak need to sit out first?

A cold medallion cooks unevenly and takes longer to reach temperature. If it has sat and is not cold anymore, 15 to 20 minutes in the low oven gets it there, and the cook stays even.

Can I do the whole thing in a pan or on the grill?

You can, but you give up the edge to edge even cook. The low oven is what keeps the whole medallion the same color from top to bottom.

What internal temperature is medium rare for tenderloin?

130 to 135 degrees after the rest. Tenderloin is lean and tender, and it dries out fast past medium, so I never take it further.

Do I have to use tenderloin?

No. I have made this with skirt steak, ribeyes, and brisket, and the chimichurri with the spread works on all of them. I pick tenderloin because it bites clean in a sandwich instead of pulling the whole piece of steak out with one bite.

How far ahead can I make the chimichurri?

A day ahead is fine and the flavor actually gets better as it sits. Keep it covered in the fridge and bring it back to room temperature before serving.

Why slice against the grain?

Cutting across the fibers shortens them, and short fibers chew tender. Slicing with the grain leaves long fibers that eat tough even on a tender cut.

What bread holds up best?

Ciabatta baguette or a crusty sourdough. The sandwich is juicy, so a soft roll falls apart before you finish it.

Additional Details

Reverse seared steak tenderloin sandwich with homemade chimichurri and mustard mayo on toasted ciabatta. Cooked to 105 in a low oven, seared to a crust, sliced thin against the grain for edge to edge medium rare in every bite.


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating